Immigration Strategies for Entrepreneurs: Comparing O1-A, EB1-A, and EB2-NIW

Written By Pathaura Law

The United States has a world-leading economy, a strong currency, and a stable legal system. These factors attract global entrepreneurs to start their careers. For non-residents, a visa is typically required before opening a business. There is no specific entrepreneur's visa, but entrepreneurs can consider several different visa types. This article will first provide an overview of three common immigration options for entrepreneurs: the O-1A visa, the EB-1A immigrant visa, and the EB-2 National Interest Waiver (NIW). Then, we will explain why the NIW can be a useful option for entrepreneurs looking for both flexibility and an efficient path to permanent residence.

O-1A (Non-Immigrant Visa)

The O-1A visa is for individuals with extraordinary abilities in the sciences, education, business, or athletics. The applicants need to prove their extraordinary ability through sustained national or international recognition and demonstrate their temporary stay in the U.S. for continuing work in their area of expertise.[1]

O-1 visas offer entrepreneurs several advantages:

  • No Educational Requirements:

    Unlike the H-1B, which favors individuals who left school to start businesses or hold degrees unrelated to their current field of work.

  • No Mandatory Minimum Wage Regulations:

    Startup founders are given flexibility in deciding how to compensate themselves.

  • Not Subject to Annual Lotteries:

    Applicants can file at any time without numerical limits.

However, there are also some disadvantages for entrepreneurs:

  • Cannot Self‑petition:

    A U.S. employer or agent must file an O-1; founders cannot self-petition. Entrepreneurs need to establish a separate legal entity or agent that meets USCIS requirements. In addition, your employer or agent must clearly define employment terms (such as contracts, wages, and itinerary), have the authority to hire and supervise you, and an authentic employer-employee relationship.[2]

    In contrast, immigrant options favored by many entrepreneurs, such as EB-1A and EB-2 NIW, permit self-petition and provide more control and a direct path to permanent residence.

  • High evidentiary bar:

    USCIS regulation requires “a level of expertise indicating that the person is one of the small percentage who have arisen to the very top of the field of endeavor.”[3] It is difficult for many founders to meet this standard in the early stages of a company.

  • Visa Duration and Limitations:

    O-1 is a non-immigrant visa, not a permanent residence status. An initial stay is up to three years; extensions are typically granted in one-year increments. For entrepreneurs, there is less stability when it comes to building a business due to this.

The O-1A visa provides entrepreneurs with flexibility, but its limitations, such as no self-petition, a high burden of evidence, and temporary status, make it more suitable for short-term use. The EB-1A or EB-2 NIW may offer a more stable long-term path.

EB-1A (Extraordinary Ability visa)

EB-1A and O-1A are similar in that both require proof of extraordinary ability. However, the EB-1A is an immigrant visa leading to permanent residence, while the O-1A is a non-immigrant visa for temporary stay. Although the evidentiary criteria overlap, obtaining an EB-1A is generally more challenging because USCIS enforces a stricter standard.

Entrepreneurs applying for EB-1A have some advantages listed below:

  • Current priority dates for most nationalities:

    For applicants from most countries (except China and India), the EB-1 category is current on the Visa Bulletin.[4] This means that once your I-140 petition is approved, you can immediately apply for adjustment of status and receive a green card without long waiting times.

  • No job offer or labor certification required:

    Unlike many employment-based green card categories, EB-1A allows self-petitioning. Business owners and founders do not need a U.S. employer sponsor or a permanent job offer.

  • Direct path to permanent residence:

    The EB-1A visa is not a temporary visa; it can lead directly to permanent residence. O-1A, on the other hand, is a non-immigrant visa that allows only temporary residency.

There are also some challenges that entrepreneurs face when applying for EB1-A:

  • Too Rigid to Prove:

    An EB-1A visa requires a major international award or evidence that you have met at least 3 of 10 criteria, such as scholarly publications, prestigious prizes, or leadership roles in distinguished organizations.[5] Some entrepreneurs may have difficulty meeting these rigid standards due to their achievements not aligning with academic or artistic benchmarks.

  • Must Demonstrate Work Continuity:

    EB‑1A does not require a job offer. However, petitioners must demonstrate that "you are coming to (or remaining in) the United States to continue to work in your area of extraordinary ability and your entry will substantially benefit the United States." When entrepreneurs' roles are evolving or involve investment rather than day-to-day operations, it can be difficult to demonstrate concrete future engagement.

The EB-1A gives entrepreneurs self-petitioning and a direct route to permanent residence, but its strict evidentiary standards and work continuity requirements make it harder to obtain.

EB-2 NIW (National Interest Waiver)

Entrepreneurs must demonstrate their qualifications (degree or exceptional ability), show that their work will provide significant prospective benefit to the U.S., and meet the three-prong test: The applicant's proposed endeavor has substantial merit and national importance, the applicant is well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor, and it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of the PERM labor certification. Because entrepreneurs often follow nontraditional career paths and start-ups vary in structure, USCIS allows flexibility by accepting a wide range of evidence to show merit, national importance, and the petitioner’s ability to advance the endeavor.

Below, we will explain why the NIW often presents a more advantageous option for entrepreneurs:

  • Lower Evidentiary Threshold:

    NIW applicants need only show their endeavor has merit and national importance, that they are well-positioned, and that waiving the job offer benefits the U.S.. This is easier than EB-1A’s requirement to prove they are at the very top of their field, making NIW more accessible for entrepreneurs.

  • Broader Definition of “Exceptional Ability”:

    USCIS defines exceptional ability as “expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered” (8 CFR §204.5(k)(2)). Entrepreneurs can use varied evidence, such as experience, memberships, or patents. If regulatory standards do not directly apply to entrepreneurs' occupations, they can provide “comparable evidence” when standard criteria are not suitable, offering founders additional options to qualify.

  • Flexibility in Employment:

    NIW waives the job offer and labor certification requirement (INA §203(b)(2)(B)(i)). This allows entrepreneurs to submit self-petitions and modify their roles as startups progress, without being bound to a single employer.

  • Direct Path to Green Card:

    Because EB-2 NIW is an immigrant visa, it offers a direct route to permanent residence. This gives entrepreneurs long-term stability and freedom.

Comparison Table: O-1A, EB-1A, and EB-2 NIW

Conclusion

There are multiple visa options available to entrepreneurs, but each has its own benefits and limitations. O-1A visas offer short-term flexibility, but lack permanence, while EB-1A offers green cards through self-petitioning but requires a very high standard of evidence. In contrast, the EB-2 NIW is well-suited for founders because of its lower criteria, broader definition of exceptional ability, employment flexibility, and direct path to permanent residence. The NIW represents the practical and strategic route to building a solid future in the United States for many entrepreneurs. Each case is unique; it is important to consult with an experienced immigration attorney to determine the best strategy. Pathaura Law PLLC has extensive experience assisting entrepreneurs with NIW applications and can offer personalized guidance to improve your chances of success.

Pathaura Law
Next

How to Decide Between Regular and Premium Processing for an EB2-NIW Filing